Audit and Benchmarking of Supermarket Catalog Composition in Five Countries
The role of the catalog in retail advertising remains important, even as advertising is gradually shifting to digital formats. The overarching objective of this study is to synthesize current practices in supermarket catalogs, identify key trends in content, composition, format, and layout, and compare results across countries. This paper investigates the content of 39 catalogs from 13 supermarket chains in five countries (Australia, Malaysia, New Zealand, South Africa, and the United States). The coding scheme and variables are based on main design elements in print advertising to examine the catalogs objectively. The results show that catalogs are no longer just advertising temporary price reductions but have evolved into a media tool to promote supermarkets’ product range, including full-price products. This study applies findings from print media to the supermarket catalog sector and provides a quantitative benchmark for typical content, composition, format, and layout, comparing results across countries.
CitationTan, P.J., Tanusondjaja, A., Corsi, A., Lockshin, L., Villani, C. and Bogomolova, S. (2022) "Audit and Benchmarking of Supermarket Catalog Composition in Five Countries". Forthcoming in the International Journal of Advertising.
Mind the attention gap: How does digital advertising impact choice under low attention?
The purpose of this study was to investigate whether digital advertising can be effective despite consumer inattention, and how certain common combinations of ad characteristics increase or decrease ad effectiveness under conditions of low attention.
We found that ad exposure under low attention does increase brand consideration and choice. The greatest uplift in impact occurs when moving from non-exposure to incidental attention. Under incidental attention, emotive advertising was more effective than rational advertising, as was matching rather than mismatching an emotional appeal to a hedonic brand. Conversely, under divided attention, rational advertising and mismatching a rational appeal to a hedonic brand was more effective.
CitationSantoso, I., Wright, M.J., Trinh, G. and Avis, M. (2021), "Mind the attention gap: how does digital advertising impact choice under low attention?". Forthcoming in the European Journal of Marketing
Marketing Research on Mobile Apps: Past, Present and Future
We present an integrative review of existing marketing research on mobile apps, clarifying and expanding what is known around how apps shape customer experiences and value across iterative customer journeys, leading to the attainment of competitive advantage, via apps (in instances of apps attached to an existing brand) and for apps (when the app is the brand). To synthetize relevant knowledge, we integrate different conceptual bases into a unified framework, which simplifies the results of an in-depth bibliographic analysis of 471 studies. The synthesis advances marketing research by combining customer experience, customer journey, value creation and co-creation, digital customer orientation, market orientation, and competitive advantage. This integration of knowledge also furthers scientific marketing research on apps, facilitating future developments on the topic and promoting expertise exchange between academia and industry.
CitationStocchi, L., Pourazad, N., Michaelidou, N., Tanusondjaja, A. and Harrigan, P (2021) "Marketing Research on Mobile Apps: Past, Present and Future". Forthcoming in the Journals of the Academy of Marketing Science.
Seasonal differences in the cost and engagement of Facebook advertisements for a physical activity smartphone app
Social networks including Facebook appear to be an ideal platform for delivering health-related marketing campaigns. They offer a large, engaged audience, and the ability to deliver advertisements to segments of the population, based on characteristics such as age, gender, geographic location, and interests.
Health researchers and health promotion practitioners, who have limited advertising budgets, need to identify optimal conditions for their health promotion campaigns to achieve maximum impact. Better understanding of how cost and engagement with physical activity advertisement vary will help practitioners schedule their promotion campaigns more effectively and maximise their campaign’s chances of success at optimal budgets.
A key consideration for delivering an advertising campaign on a limited budget is whether the effectiveness of an advertisement will differ based on the time of year.
This novel study aimed to address these knowledge deficits by examining the cost and engagement levels of a Facebook advertising campaign for an evidence-based physical activity app delivered at three timepoints.
CitationNorthcott, C., Curtis, R., Bogomolova, S., Olds, T., Vandelanotte, C., Plotnikoff, R., and Maher, C. (2021) "Seasonal differences in the cost and engagement of Facebook advertisements for a physical activity smartphone app". Forthcoming in the American Journal of Health Promotion.
Evaluating the effectiveness of a physical activity social media advertising campaign using Facebook, Facebook Messenger, and Instagram
Technology-based physical activity programs are a novel solution to the major public health issue of physical inactivity. However, to be successful, there must be a large and population- appropriate uptake, which depends heavily on promotion. This study evaluates the effectiveness of an advertising campaign to disseminate a physical activity smartphone app.
CitationNorthcott, C., Curtis, R., Bogomolova, S., Olds, T., Vandelanotte, C., Plotnikoff, R., and Maher, C. (2021). "Evaluating the effectiveness of a physical activity social media advertising campaign using Facebook, Facebook Messenger, and Instagram". Forthcoming in the Translational Behavioral Medicine.
Behavioural and Psychographic Characteristics of Supermarket Catalogue Users
Supermarket catalogues (also known as store flyers or circulars) are a popular retail tool for influencing shoppers’ behaviour and increasing store sales. Past research has documented varying effects of catalogue promotions on consumer behaviour, but it has not focused specifically on the psychographic and behavioural characteristics of catalogue users. This research aims to fill this gap through an analysis of a representative sample of 506 South Australian consumers. The results show that consumers who use supermarket catalogues are more likely to have one or more of these characteristics: price-consciousness, deal-proneness, low-income, and rarely switches brands. The contribution of this research provides empirical evidence on the user profiles of supermarket catalogues. Retailers and suppliers equipped with this knowledge can create more relevant promotions to increase efficiency and incremental sales.
CitationTan, P.J., Bogomolova, S., Tanusondjaja, A., Lockshin, L., Maria Corsi, A., and Villani, C. (2021) "Behavioural and Psychographic Characteristics of Supermarket Catalogue Users". Forthcoming in the Journal of Retailing and Consumer Science
The Impact of Autobiographical Memory on Brand Retrieval and Purchase Intention
Autobiographical memory involves mentally reliving past episodes that are personally relevant. Psychology research shows that it has remarkable bearing on one’s life, including the accomplishment of tasks, self-enhancement, self-preservation and attaining goals. Yet, the understanding of autobiographical memory in consumer behaviour research is much more limited. Accordingly, the present study evaluates the impact of two cognitive mechanisms resulting from personal past-usage experiences linked to the product category, which are likely to underpin consumers’ retrieval of brands from memory and purchase intention. The two cognitive aspects are: the cued recollection of specific autobiographical memories; and the accessibility (in memory) of autobiographical episodes of consumption that form product category knowledge. The empirical results obtained across three online experiments suggest product category knowledge accessible in consumer memory has a greater effect on brand retrieval and purchase intention than the direct recollection of specific autobiographical memories cued by the product category. Perceived importance of choice moderates this effect, which primarily concerns purchase intention. In particular, consistent with prior research on activation confusion, product category knowledge reduces purchase intention, especially for highly familiar (or prototypical) brands. Accordingly, we outline implications for branded communications, and advertising pre- and post-testing.
CitationStocchi, L., Wright, M., and Fuller, R. (2021) "The Impact of Autobiographical Memory on Brand Retrieval and Purchase Intention". Forthcoming in the Journal of Consumer Behaviour.
Measuring advertising’s effect on Mental Availability
This study shows that the impact of advertising on consumer memory can be observed using Mental Availability (MA) metrics. Four MA metrics are used to measure the effect of advertising awareness on a brand’s mental availability, with the results showing that in the majority of cases MA metrics are greater amongst both brand users and non-users who are aware of the brand’s advertising, with a greater effect amongst non-users. From a practical market research perspective adding MA metrics to existing brand health tracking will have no data collection costs where brand perceptions are already being measured.
CitationVaughan, K., Maria Corsi, A., Bea, V., Sharp, B. (2020) “Measuring advertising's effect on Mental Availability”. Forthcoming in the International Journal of Market Research.
Viewing Time as a Cross-Media Metric: Comparing Viewing Time for Video Advertising on Television and Online
The Media Rating Council recommends weighting advertising exposure by viewing time. Prior research shows viewing time has diminishing returns, implying that effectiveness equivalent to a 100% complete exposure could be achieved by a lower threshold. Results from four laboratory experiments, extending prior banner-ad research to dynamic video ads, suggest 75% viewed is a potential threshold. A second contribution identifies different viewing time distributions for television and online video, due to differences in ad avoidance. More television ads have viewing times exceeding the 75% threshold, and so are more effective than the typical online video ad. Online networks could charge fees equivalent to television ads for video ads that exceed the 75% threshold. A third contribution is the use of interval outcome estimation (IOE), which revealed asymmetric effects of viewing time and that brand familiarity rather than viewing time is the only sufficient explanation of ad effectiveness measured by recall.
CitationBellman, S., Beal, V., Wooley, B.,Varan, D. (2020) Viewing Time as a Cross-Media Metric: Comparing Viewing Time for Video Advertising on Television and Online". Forthcoming in the Journal of Business Research.
When Brands Go Dark: Examining Sales Trends When Brands Stop Broad Reach Advertising for Long Periods
Due to a variety of financial reasons, or change in strategic focus, sometimes brands stop broad reach media advertising for a year or longer. These long dark periods have not been subject to much study, so little is known about the likely consequences. This exploratory study addresses this omission by documenting the sales performance of 41 beer, cider and spirit brands that advertised on and off over almost two decades. Changes in aggregate brand sales are reported for the years when brands stopped advertising relative to the last advertised year. On average, brand sales declined immediately in the first year, and every subsequent year of advertising cessation. Decline was generally faster for smaller brands and brands already declining in sales prior to advertising cessation.
CitationHartnett, N., Gelzinis, A., Beal, V., Kennedy, R., Sharp, B. (2020) "When Brands Go Dark: Examining Sales Trends When Brands Stop Broad Reach Advertising for Long Periods". Forthcoming in the Journal of Advertising Research.