Influencers and the choice of a travel destination: a customer journey and information processing perspective
Despite growing investment and strategic emphasis on travel social media influencers (TSMI), research lacks a holistic understanding of their impact on travel decisions across different stages of the customer journey. The objective of this study is therefore to develop and validate an integrated framework that explains the effectiveness of TSMIs combining customer journey and information processing conceptual lenses. In more detail, using a mixed-methods approach involving partial least squares structural equation modelling (PLS-SEM) and fuzzy-set Qualitative Comparative Analysis (fsQCA) performed on survey data from n = 530 Australian consumers exposed to simulated Instagram content, this study identifies critical psychological mechanisms through which TSMIs impact travel decisions at the
pre-purchase, purchase and post-purchase stages. It emerges that ad informativeness and persuasiveness significantly impact destination choice, while ad identification plays a more limited role. Comprehensively, these results integrate and advance the customer journey and information processing perspectives in TSMIs research,
demonstrating how awareness, attitudes and involvement collectively shape the effectiveness of TSMIs. The results also translate into practical guidelines for optimising TSMI partnerships across different customer journey touchpoints; creating persuasive content strategies; and leveraging post-visit sharing behaviours to maximise return on investments.
CitationPourzad, N., Stocchi, L., Simmonds, L. (2025). "Influencers and the choice of a travel destination: a customer journey and information processing perspective". Forthcoming in the Information Technology and Tourism Journal.
Generational Advertising: Literature Review and Practitioner Insights on Key Pitfalls and Implications
Generational labels are widely used in popular culture to signal the values or behaviours of specific groups, making them appealing to advertisers. This paper reviews generational segmentation in advertising research and examines its practice through interviews with advertising practitioners. The paper provides an extended literature review, insights, and implications for research and practice. While generational segmentation is a convenient way to signal a cohort within the market, it should not restrict the target market. Generational labels highlight the need to understand a broader audience, especially in an industry dominated by younger professionals. However, these labels must be used thoughtfully to avoid stereotypes and create inclusive ads that resonate across all ages. We encourage advertisers and researchers to focus on shared values and behaviours across generations rather than on emphasising differences. A cross-generational approach that targets the broad market is more sustainable, supporting long-term brand building and increasing mass market awareness.
CitationCheah, I., & Phua, P. (2024). Generational advertising: literature review and practitioner insights on key pitfalls and implications. International Journal of Advertising.
How heterogeneous are music genre listeners?
Understanding music listening behaviour benefits those seeking to market music to the general population and those choosing music to feature in retail environments or advertising. In particular, understanding how consumers consume different genres is important. There are, however, two conflicting bodies of knowledge. One finds segments of music listeners who differ on music genre preferences, while the other finds (media and brand) user profiles are more similar than different. Our research provides additional evidence by surveying over 1,000 representative respondents in the United States regarding their listening behaviour of 13 music genres. The proportion of listeners of each genre is compared with the average profile for all genres using those segmentation variables previously found to cause differing genre preferences (e.g., age and income). While some minor differences exist, notably that younger listeners prefer electronica/dance, the overall results show genre user profiles are more similar than different. The theoretical implication is that using approaches designed to find minor differences will do precisely that and magnify them. At the same time, for those marketing music in the industry, achieving a broader market coverage may be more effective in expanding their listener bases than focusing on narrower segments.
CitationAnesbury, Z., Davies, C., Page, B., Driesener, C., Yang, S., Bruwer, J. (2024), "How heterogeneous are music genre listeners?". Forthcoming in the Australasian Marketing Journal.
Out of Reach or Out of Mind? Differences in Advertising’s Effectiveness Across Age Groups
Our research explores differences in cognitive evaluative measures of consumer buying behaviour and advertising’s effectiveness across age groups. We seek to ascertain if older segments show dissimilar memory structures and cognitive processes than younger targets, or if modern advertising approaches are simply lacking reach among older consumers. Our main measure of interest is mental availability – i.e., the ease at which a brand comes to mind in buying situations. We compare the scores of three underlying mental availability metrics across age groups and find differences primarily for associative penetration, a proxy for advertising reach. We then examine differences in other important cognitive evaluative measures of advertising effectiveness, such as the purchase funnel (narrowing down of alternatives for purchase) and product category knowledge. We detect additional differences that further illustrate why there are likely limits to advertising’s reach amongst older consumers. Hence, we stress the importance of using these cognitive evaluative measures to appraise the effectiveness of inclusive, cross-age advertising strategies in theory and practice.
CitationMecredy, P., Stocchi, L., Feetham, P. (2024), "Out of Reach or Out of Mind? Differences in Advertising’s Effectiveness Across Age Groups". Forthcoming in International Journal of Advertising.
The Mirror Effect in Online Survey Data: Evidence and Implications for Marketing Theory and Strategy
This research reveals the presence, in online survey data, of a key pattern documented in psychology lab research: the Mirror Effect. The Mirror Effect occurs when unfamiliar stimuli are unexpectedly recognised as accurately as familiar stimuli, or more accurately. Using a set of familiar and unfamiliar words (as determined by lexical frequency), we first report that we can robustly replicate psychology lab research in an online survey, detecting the Mirror Effect. We then apply the same analytical approach to surveying consumer recognition of everyday brands (supermarkets, banks, and car brands). We find that unfamiliar brands can be recognized with the same level of accuracy as familiar brands, and this effect is stronger than age and gender memory biases present in the data. However, we detect a boundary condition for branded apps, which are extremely unfamiliar brands competing in highly fragmented marketplaces, so very few get downloaded or used. For these digital brands, we find a Concordant Effect, as most respondents find it difficult to recognise highly unfamiliar branded apps (i.e., those with fewer than 5,000 downloads). The Mirror Effect re-emerges for highly experienced app users. These results demonstrate the implications of a generalisable empirical pattern from cognitive psychology for branding and advertising theory. The outcomes of this research also translate into practical guidelines for brand performance measurement via online surveys, mitigating recognition memory bias for the development of marketing strategies based on more accurate interpretation of empirical evidence.
CitationStocchi, L., Bellman, S., Pourazad, N., Michaelidou, N., & Wright, M. (2024). The mirror effect in online survey data: Evidence and implications for marketing theory and strategy. Psychology & Marketing, 1–16
Why Shorter Advertisement Breaks Reduce Radio Ad Avoidance: When it Comes to Radio Advertising, Less is More
Low-clutter radio stations have shorter ad breaks to attract listeners, increase ad-effectiveness, and potentially reduce mechanical ad-avoidance. This research introduces a two-factor theory explaining why mechanical ad avoidance has an inverse U-shaped relationship with ad-position in the break, and ad-break length in ad-units. The theory was supported by portable people meter (PPM) ratings data. Peak mechanical avoidance occurred at the fourth ad position, similar to the average ad-break length perceived by radio listeners from the same city as the PPM data. This explains why the two-ad breaks typical for low-clutter radio stations minimize mechanical avoidance.
CitationMichelon, A., Bellman, S., Faulkner, M., Cohen, J., Bruwer, J. (2023). “Why Shorter Advertisement Breaks Reduce Radio Ad Avoidance: When it Comes to Radio Advertising, Less is More”. Forthcoming in the Journal of Advertising Research.
Childhood Exposure to Brands: Comparing Age of Acquisition Effects with Ongoing Brand Exposure and Experience
The age of acquisition (AoA) effect suggests that things learned early in life, including brand names, are recognized more quickly and accurately. This study confirms this effect but cautions that the managerial impact of AoA is small. Brand exposure frequency and usage recency have a far greater effect on recognition than AoA. The strongest AoA effect is observed among individuals unfamiliar with the brand, suggesting repetition, such as advertising, is necessary. Respondents were slower to identify brands released before age ≈15, indicating memory-based processes occur for early-learned brands, while later-learned brands relied more on non-memory-based processes like guessing.
CitationPhua, P., Page, B., Trinh, G., Hartnett, N., Kennedy, R. (2023). “Childhood Exposure to Brands: Comparing Age of Acquisition Effects With Ongoing Brand Exposure and Experience”. Forthcoming in the Journal of Advertising Research.
When Brands Go Dark: A Replication and Extension
The value of mass media advertising can be demonstrated by quantifying what happens when it is removed. This study does this, extending Hartnett et al. (2021), by documenting changes in market share for 365 US brands from 22 consumer goods categories that stopped advertising for at least one year. Market shares of brands without advertising declined, on average, at a steady rate year-overyear. On average, market share declines were more common and substantial among small brands and those losing share before advertising ceased. The magnitude of market share decline varied considerably across categories. Consumer goods with longer interpurchase intervals appear to suffer greater average decreases after three years without advertising. That prior findings generalize to a new market and many new categories increases confidence in the results.
CitationPhua, P., Hartnett, N., Beal, V., Trinh, G. & Kennedy, R. (2023). "When Brands Go Dark: A Replication and Extension". Journal of Advertising Research, May 2023, 2023-009
Reaching Voters on Social Media: Planning Political Advertising on Snapchat
Over the past decade, political advertising via social media has grown rapidly, spurred by microtargeting, which looks to deliver specific messages to tightly defined audiences. Microtargeting strategies have been claimed to be effective, but questions remain around their cost, when looking to optimise impressions for a given budget. We analyse 11,837 ads aired on Snapchat over a two-year period leading up to the 2020 presidential election in the United States, which differ in the number of targeting criteria applied. We compare the number of impressions and the spend per ad placement (measured in CPM), also considering the length of advertising schedule. We find that using fewer targeting criteria and longer schedules increases impressions with comparable or lower spend than microtargeting. These findings are in line with those from traditional broadcast media, such as TV, highlighting the relevance of existing media scheduling knowledge from traditional platforms for political advertising on newer, digital media.
CitationTanusondjaja, A., Michelon, A., Hartnett, N., Stocchi, L. (2023) "Reaching Voters on Social Media: Planning Political Advertising on Snapchat". Forthcoming in the International Journal of Market Research.
Can muted video advertising be as effective as video advertising with sound?
Video ads are often muted when seen in social media on a smartphone. This research compared video ads across three Muting conditions: (1) normal (audio), (2) muted, and (3) muted with subtitles. The lab-study results showed that muted ads had lower free brand recall, cued brand recall, and brand recognition than normal ads and adding subtitles did not improve effectiveness on these measures. However, the results suggest that muting makes little difference to the effectiveness of video ads seen in social media on smartphones.
CitationBellman, S, Arismendez, S & Varan, D (2021) 'Can muted video advertising be as effective as video advertising with sound?' forthcoming in SN Business & Economics.